Hi…I never heard of the changes!!!! Tony
From: cohsl-list-bounces@lists.fas.harvard.edu
[mailto:cohsl-list-bounces@lists.fas.harvard.edu] On Behalf Of Lesage,
Rhea
Sent: Wednesday, February 24, 2010 8:50 AM
To: listserv for the Consortium of Hellenic Studies Librarians
Cc: Hazen, Dan; Scott, Alison
Subject: [Cohsl-list] FW: Greek transliteration
All, this is the message that I wrote to Bob Hiatt from LC in
Dec. 2008. He was in touch at that time asking my feedback on proposed tables,
which confused transcription with transliteration. He also brought up the issue
of the rough breathing, for which I offered a solution. I bolded the part of
the message in which I suggested that we open the discussion up to the
cataloging and Modern Greek Studies communities. I never got a reply from him,
but it seems that he went ahead and implemented the change that now appears on
the LC website. I would like to know if ANYONE heard about these supposed
“2009 changes” before yesterday. Please respond to this list!
--Rhea
From: Lesage, Rhea
Sent: Tuesday, February 23, 2010 4:09 PM
To: Lesage, Rhea
Subject: FW: Greek transliteration
From: Rhea Karabelas Lesage
[mailto:karabel@fas.harvard.edu]
Sent: Friday, December 12, 2008 6:04 PM
To: Robert Miller Hiatt
Cc: Rhea Karabelas Lesage
Subject: Greek transliteration
Hi, Bob:
Thank you for getting in touch about changes to the Greek tables, and for
returning my call to discuss this over the phone. I wanted to give you my
feedback and suggestions as a follow-up.
First of all, we agree that respecting the "h" for the rough
breathing mark that is no longer there, no longer seems to make sense and
continues to be an out-dated practice. This system, however archaic as it may
seem, is something we all seem to manage--there is a finite group of words that
require the rough breathing. If it would help we could compile a list as an
addendum to the existing tables. It should also be noted that there are still
many modern Greek authors who intentionally write using polytonic Greek (which
includes the rough breathing). Whatever decision is made we need to allow for
this practice and prescribe how catalogers should handle it.
My feedback on proposed tables:
I hope this summarizes what we
discussed and please let me know if you have any questions or if we need
further discussion.
Best wishes,
Rhea
Rhea K. Lesage
Head and Bibliographer for Modern Greek
Modern Greek Section
Collection Development Department
Widener Library
Harvard College Library
Cambridge, MA 02138
(617)495-3632
FAX (617)496-8704